I know many people
groan when they hear a pun; in fact, I’ve heard people say that puns are just a
“low form” of humor. However, according to this anonymous writer of Rhetorica ad Herennium, puns can
actually be considered an element of elegant style. Now as you’re flipping the
pages again trying to find the word “pun,” you won’t find it; instead, look for
the word “transplacement” (pg 254). The writer defines a subcategory of
transplacement in which “the same word is used first in one function, and then
in another.” Then the example he gives is as follows: “I would leave this
place, should the Senator give me leave.” Does this not match the definition of
a pun?
As we’re
studying rhetoric, we may have to change our perspective about certain
rhetorical devices. We currently might have this preconceived notion that puns
are frowned upon in academia, and therefore, we must avoid using them at all
costs. In contrast to the accusation that puns are a “low” form of humor, I
suggest that puns denote sophistication because you have to have a good grasp
of language in order to make or understand them. Plus, puns don’t have to be
used just for humor; John Pollack, a former presidential speechwriter, stated
that “The power of a pun comes from two things. One is its ambiguity, and
second is that it enables you to pack more meaning, or more layers of meaning,
into fewer words. And so if you're trying to convey complex ideas, puns can be
really powerful tools to do that” (Not Jest for Pun). Even from antiquity and through the ages, we find instances where great writers
interlaced puns throughout their writings (Examples of Puns in Literature).
C'mon Sadie, I was hoping you'd say it was pretty punny! I enjoyed your post, and I'm struck by how different of a message you have taken away from this reading than I have. I read Anon.'s section on puns, and still I feel they are a "low", or rather unsophisticated form of expression. I suppose that it's more the clash of humor with academia that stands out to me- I'm not really one for writing in a humorous style (I like pretty words), but I can absolutely see your point that the scrutiny is misplaced. Well thought out and cited- thanks!
ReplyDelete